Cost of Restriction
Restricting Credit Access Has Big Consequences
If short-term borrowing is restricted or eliminated, where will Texans turn?

The Alternatives Can Cost More
Annual Percentage Rate of Short-Term Lending Alternatives
Expand any option for the calculation and its source.
Bank Overdrafts
17,236%
Annualized from one CFPB example: a $34 fee on a $24 overdraft repaid in three days. Not a rate every account is charged; some banks have reduced or removed overdraft fees.
Utility Late And Shutoff Costs
Up to 913%
Annualized equivalent of a $50 reconnection charge on a $200 bill resolved over 10 days. Charges vary by provider and approved tariff.
Texas Rent Late Fees
Up to 626%
An annualized cost comparison on $1,500 rent paid 7 days late, not a legally defined APR.
Credit Cards With Late Payment Fees
Up to 4,171%
Annualized equivalent of a $32 late fee on a missed $40 minimum payment resolved after seven days, not the card's ongoing interest rate, which averages about 22%.
Unlicensed, Illegal And Overseas Lenders
Over 1,000%
Documented in federal enforcement cases against illegal internet lending operations.
Cartel And Criminal Lending Activity
Unregulated
Not a rate but an absence of one: no disclosures, no consumer protections, and in some documented cases extortion and violence.
Government Mandated Interest Rate Caps Put Credit Out of Reach for Millions of Households
A recent 2026 Federal Reserve Bank of New York research found that state interest-rate caps caused loan balances to decline substantially among the riskiest borrowers. Those borrowers carried less debt, but researchers found no corresponding improvement in their delinquency rates. The findings indicate that caps primarily rationed credit rather than converting higher-cost loans into lower-cost loans for the same consumers. Federal Reserve Bank of New York(opens in a new tab)
Federal Reserve research also recognizes that higher-risk loans carry higher expected losses. When lenders cannot price for that risk, they may decide the loan cannot be offered sustainably. Federal Reserve Board(opens in a new tab)
Interest Rate Caps Cases
Oregon
After Oregon imposed a restrictive rate cap, payday borrowing declined, but former borrowers shifted partly to bank overdrafts and late bill payments. The study also found evidence of deterioration in borrowers’ overall financial condition.
Georgia
A Federal Reserve Bank of New York study found that after Georgia prohibited payday lending, households bounced more checks, filed more Chapter 7 bankruptcies and submitted more complaints about lenders and debt collectors. North Carolina’s results were largely unchanged, demonstrating that effects are not identical everywhere.
Illinois Case Study
Downloadable one-pager
After Illinois imposed a 36% rate cap, loans to higher-risk borrowers fell by about 45% and 56% of former borrowers surveyed could no longer borrow, leaving many to pay bills late or turn to costlier options.
If Short-Term Borrowing Is Restricted or Eliminated, Where Will Texans Turn?
Before policymakers eliminate a regulated financial option, they must answer a basic question: Where will families turn instead?
Few alternatives satisfy all six conditions. Earned-wage access, for example, can help an employed person who has already earned sufficient wages, but it cannot necessarily provide $800 for an emergency at the beginning of a pay period. Buy Now Pay Later can finance a qualifying purchase but cannot usually pay the electric bill. A bank loan may cost less but be unavailable to the consumer who needs it.
Even credit-union Payday Alternative Loans are not purely free-market replacements: they operate within a special federal regulatory framework, require credit-union access and are limited in amount and terms. Current federal rules permit qualifying PALs to carry rates of up to 28%. NCUA guidance(opens in a new tab)
A Workable Substitute Must Do All Of The Following
- Provide money immediately.
- Serve consumers with poor or limited credit.
- Offer relatively small amounts.
- Cover unrestricted needs such as rent, utilities or repairs.
- Operate at sufficient scale.
- Generate enough revenue to cover underwriting, servicing, defaults and compliance.

Alternatives Should Compete With Credit, Not Eliminate It
The market should be encouraged to develop more affordable choices, not prevented from serving consumers whose needs are difficult or expensive to meet. Bank loans, fintech products, employer advances and earned-wage access can provide valuable alternatives, but none currently serves every consumer or every emergency. Eliminating one form of regulated credit before viable replacements exist does not create a better option; it can leave families with no workable option at all.
TAKE ACTION